Last updated: February 19, 2019

Best Hypoallergenic Makeup For Sensitive skin – Top 9 Reviewed

Sara Fletcher
Published 3:15 am

I love makeup.

I feel like a movie star when I wear the perfect combination of eyeshadow shades and plump up my lips with the newest shade of lip gloss. But I hate when my makeup leaves my skin blotchy, red and irritated.

Did you know that you can be allergic to ingredients in makeup?

If your skin seems to be in worse shape at the end of the day, there’s a good chance it’s your makeup. The best hypoallergenic makeup for sensitive skin could make all the difference.

Quick Comparison

Product Name


Editor Rating

Mia Adora 3D Fiber Lash Mascara


Lash Factory InstaLash One-Step 3D Mascara


Love Alpha Bella Rose 3D Fiber Lash Mascara


Mystere Cosmetics Mascara


Lash Factory Eyelash Growth Serum


J.Cat Beauty Roll It Up Auto Lip Pencil Liner


Sofies Secret Makeup Remover Facial Pads


Amalie Wink Lash & Brow Enhancing Oil Vegan


Almay One Coat Nourishing Mascara


If you’re interested in finding the best hypoallergenic makeup, take a look at my reviews of hypoallergenic eye makeup and more. You’re sure to find the perfect products for your sensitive skin.

Mia Adora 3d Fiber Lash Mascara

This hypoallergenic mascara does it all. It’s water and smudge resistant and doesn’t leave those nasty clumps behind.

I found that it last all day, even on those that I had to spend a few extra hours at the office.

You won’t find toxic ingredients in this mascara. It actually strengthens and conditions your natural eyelashes.

Hypoallergenic makeup Mia Adora 3d Fiber Lash MascaraBuy for $$ on Amazon

And if you’re an animal lover, you’ll be happy to know that Mia Adora never tests their products on our furry friends.

Lash Factory Instalash One-Step 3d Mascara

If you want knockout lashes in a flash, InstaLash is the fastest way to achieve your goal.

It goes on just like a regular mascara and provides dramatic 3D results that are sure to get noticed.

I loved that this mascara contained all natural green tea microfibers. It was like my lashes were instantly doubled and just with one swipe.

This is my go-to mascara for days that I’m short on time but still need to look my best.

Hypoallergenic makeup Lash Factory Instalash One-Step 3d MascaraBuy for $$ on Amazon

Love Alpha Bella Rose 3d Fiber Lash Mascara

You can skip the eyelash extensions if you’re using Love Alpha Bella Rose Mascara.

My lashes were instantly full, voluminous and dare I say, a little bit sexy.

I’ll admit that I caught myself looking in the mirror a few extra times than normal when using this mascara.

Hypoallergenic makeup Love Alpha Bella Rose 3d Fiber Lash MascaraBuy for $$ on Amazon

I just couldn’t believe how great my lashes looked. And of course, my eyes weren’t irritated at all because there are no toxic ingredients.

Mystere Cosmetics Mascara

Mystere claims that their mascara can increase the volume and thickness of your lashes by up to 300%.

I’d have to say that their estimate is pretty darn close. While using this mascara, my eyelashes were of course darker but also longer and thicker.

You’ll receive a gel color and fibers with this mascara. Use a light hand to apply them so that they don’t clump up on you.

Once you get the technique down, you’ll be blown away by the difference.

Hypoallergenic makeup Mystere Cosmetics MascaraBuy for $$ on Amazon

There’s such a difference that you might just feel naked without your mascara on.

Lash Factory Eyelash Growth Serum

How would you like to improve the look of your natural lashes?

Lash Factory’s Eyelash Growth Serum does just that and without any parabens or other not so friendly ingredients.

It’s gentle for anyone with sensitive eyes and if you wear contact lenses, like I do, you don’t have to worry about the serum getting underneath a lens and causing redness or irritation.

You can use this serum on both your eyelashes and eyebrows.

Hypoallergenic makeup Lash Factory Eyelash Growth SerumBuy for $$ on Amazon

You can expect to see thicker and healthier lashes in as little as three weeks.

It took about a month for me but I can’t believe how great my eyelashes can look without mascara. Now I don’t feel like I have to put on makeup if I’m just running a quick errand or going for a jog.

J.Cat Beauty Roll It Up Auto Lip Pencil Liner

When you have sensitive skin, you probably avoid wearing extra cosmetics, like lip liner.

But now you can enjoy all of your favorite types of makeup by wearing J.Cat Beauty’s pencil liner. This product is truly high quality. It’s long lasting and incredibly easy to apply.

Many hypoallergenic makeup brands are a little pricy. But you’ll find that this pencil liner is both affordable and great for both everyday wear and special occasions.

Hypoallergenic makeup J.Cat Beauty Roll It Up Auto Lip Pencil LinerBuy for $$ on Amazon

I found that I could wear the lip liner alone or with my favorite lipstick. Even lip balm looked great with this liner.

SofiesSecret Makeup Remover Facial Pads

It won’t do any good to wear skin friendly makeup if you’re taking it off with harsh soaps or cleansers. That’s what makes SofiesSecret Facial Pads so great.

You can remove your makeup and clean your face at the end of the day with their hypoallergenic and fragrance free pads.

I loved how these pads smelled. There was a subtle hint of cucumber and they were incredibly soft.

Most importantly, they were effective. I wasn’t left with “racoon eyes” or smudged lines. My skin was clean, happy and healthy.

Hypoallergenic makeup SofiesSecret Makeup Remover Facial PadsBuy for $ on Amazon

Amalie Wink Lash & Brow Enhancing Oil Vegan

Here’s another natural hypoallergenic lash and brow enhancer. It can help you grow up to 60 new lashes!

You can throw away your lash extensions for sure after using this product for about a month.

It also works on eyebrows, which is why I decided to try it in the first place. I had gotten a little tweezer happy in the bathroom one night and overplucked my brows.

I applied this oil every night without fail and within a few weeks, I could see my eyebrows beginning to fill in again. It was a life saver!

Hypoallergenic makeup Amalie Wink Lash & Brow Enhancing Oil VeganBuy for $$$ on Amazon

Almay One Coat Nourishing Mascara

If you’ve been looking for makeup tips for sensitive eyes, one of the first that you’re likely to come across is to limit your use of mascara.

With Almay One Coat, you don’t have to give up your love for mascara. You’ll only need one swipe to get the dark, full lashes that you’re after.

Almay’s extra gentle and non irritating formula is great for avoiding itchy redness that can be all too common with regular mascara.

Hypoallergenic makeup Almay One Coat Nourishing MascaraBuy for $ on Amazon

If your budget is holding you back from purchasing hypoallergenic mascara, this brand comes in under the average price.

What is Hypoallergenic Makeup For Sensitive Skin?

Hypoallergenic makeup is less likely than regular cosmetics to cause allergic reactions. The makeup should be gentler on your skin and in most cases even safer.

Hypoallergenic cosmetics are also less likely to cause breakouts and clog pores.

Most cosmetics contain zinc oxide and titanium oxide. These compounds aren’t necessarily dangerous but when they’re broken down into fine particles for cosmetic uses, makeup is able to enter skin cells and essentially your bloodstream.

This can lead to serious irritation, rashes and other not so fun side effects.

It’s not hard to switch to using makeup, like hypoallergenic eyeliner, that’s more skin-friendly. With a little knowledge and some extra cash, you can change your makeup drawer from scary to skin-friendly in no time.

Are There Benefits of Using The Best Hypoallergenic Makeup?

If you’re on the fence about making the switch to greener cosmetics, consider the following benefits. There’s a lot more than you might think!

  • Less Breakouts: If you seem to be always trying to conceal pimples and breakouts, switching to a hypoallergenic foundation can make a huge difference. You can still cover up current acne while taking a positive step in preventing future breakouts.
  • Avoid Allergic Reactions: This is probably the greatest benefit you’ll experience when making the switch to hypoallergenic eyeliner and other products. Say goodbye to red spots, puffiness and irritation for good!
  • Improved Overall Health: Your skin is your body’s largest organ. Anything that you put on your skin can enter your bloodstream and travel through your entire body. This should serve as motivation enough to think twice about what you’re putting on your face.
  • High Quality: Just as organic food typically costs more than non-organic, you can expect to pay a bit more for hypoallergenic mascara and other products. But this also means that the products you’re using are of a higher quality than what you were using before. Your makeup will look better, stay longer and won’t irritate your skin.

What Are Common Allergic Reactions to Makeup?

An FDA survey found that up to 25% of people have had an allergic reaction to at least one beauty product, including hair products, perfumes and makeup.

There are two types of skin reactions that you might experience.

  • Irritant Contact Dermatitis: This type of reaction occurs when a product actually damages the skin. You might experience stinging, itching, burning or redness at the sight of application. In extreme circumstances, you can experience blisters and oozing.
  • Allergic Contact Dermatitis: This type of reaction involves the immune system. Symptoms include itching, swelling, redness and even hives. The skin can get very irritated and raw, leading to infections. These types of reactions can occur anywhere but are mostly found on the face, lips, eyes, ears and neck.

What Causes the Allergic Reactions?

Basic makeup can contain a variety of ingredients that have been linked to allergic reactions. Do your favorite cosmetics contain any of the following?

  • Phthalates: This ingredient is considered to be a potential carcinogen. It has also been linked to birth defects and allergic rashes.
  • Shea Butter: For most people, this ingredient is harmless. But for anyone with a nut allergy, severe allergic reactions can occur.
  • Formaldehyde: Plenty of beauty products contain formaldehyde releasing agents. Look out for imadazolidinyl urea or quaternium 15, preservatives that can give off dangerous formaldehyde fumes. Redness is a common side effect.
  • Parabens: Parabens are found in plenty of cosmetics because they’re an affordable preservatives. Unfortunately, they’re a common cause behind rashes and redness.

This is just a short list of makeup ingredients that can take away from the fun of getting ready for date night. Take a look at the ingredients of some of your current cosmetics.

You might be surprised at what you’ve been putting on your face for so long.

How Can I Tell If I Have Sensitive Skin or Eyes?

Many women feel that they have sensitive skin. The truth is that a much smaller percentage actually do while others suffer from skin conditions like rosacea.

However, if you feel that your makeup is playing a hand in the condition of your skin, take a look at these common symptoms of sensitive skin and eyes.

  • Breakouts
  • Redness
  • Blotchy Patches
  • Rashes

As far as your eyes go, if you find them watering or itchy, especially after applying eyeliner or mascara, it might be time to consider using hypoallergenic eye makeup.

How to Reduce the Risk of Allergic Reactions

Reducing allergic reactions isn’t impossible. In fact, simply making the switch to using makeup for sensitive skin is enough to stop reactions in their tracks.

Try switching out your regular shampoo for hypoallergenic shampoo or using aloe vera for acne instead of harsh products. You can also take a few other steps to protecting your skin.

  • Read Labels: Know what’s in your makeup. Usually, the fewer ingredients in a cosmetic, the less chance there is of a reaction. This will also give you the chance to rule out certain brands that contain common ingredients that tend to give you flare ups.
  • Test Products: Always do a test patch when trying out a new cosmetic. Place a small amount on the inside of your elbow and wait a couple of days. If there are no signs of a reaction, you’re probably good to go to use it as intended.
  • Monitor skin: Keep close tabs on the condition of your skin, especially when trying out new products. While you have a better chance of avoiding allergic reactions when using the best hypoallergenic makeup brands, there’s always a risk. Monitor your skin so that you can narrow down which products might be causing irritation.

Wearing makeup should be fun and a way to express yourself and raise your self-esteem. But when it causes reactions and discomfort, there’s no need to avoid cosmetics.

Switching to hypoallergenic makeup for sensitive eyes and skin is the best way to still enjoy wearing makeup while avoiding uncomfortable reactions.

When you start using the best hypoallergenic makeup for sensitive skin, you’ll wonder why you waited so long. Make the switch today. It’s the best thing I’ve ever done for my skin.

Rating: 5.0/5. From 1 vote.
Please wait...